Skip to main content

Why Grades Still Matter


The phenomenon of "easy versus hard" teachers probably dates back to Socrates. Some teachers love giving A’s to students.
On the other hand, plenty of education theory supports the claim that teacher expectations are positively associated with student achievement. This is not elitism but a philosophy of value-added instruction.
Intentional teaching means putting in the extra work and encouragement needed to help students attain difficult goals.
High standards coupled with high expectations — including encouragement— create real student success.
Who is the customer? We live in an era of grade inflation. The consumer model has twisted our priorities at every level. It isn’t even a good consumer model, which can work well if the right consumer is served.
A student once asked why I didn’t consider him my customer. If he paid his tuition shouldn’t I supply his demand for a degree? I replied, "Yes, you are my customer — but not the you of today. My customer is the you 10 years from now, who is going to thank me for upholding the standards." I made that claim based on years of hearing and reading such comments from former students, thanking me for, as one of them put it, "holding my feet to the fire."
As for administrators, we’re worried about enrollment and persistence. The only time I’ve known administrators to express much concern about grades was to accost maths and science teachers for weeding out too many students.
No one in the academic system needs to care about grade inflation so there is no check on it.
I can only see reasons to raise standards, not diminish them. Our graduates deserve the tools and confidence to compete.
Students are born to excel. When we demand more of them, coupled with a positive teaching attitude, they achieve more. Conversely, if I set the bar low it is unrealistic to think they will greatly surpass those minimal expectations. I’m no elitist, just someone who quietly maintain the standards and watches students rise to the occasion.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Reaction to Globalization

Globalization and the attendant concerns about poverty and inequality have become a focus of discussion in a way that few other topics, except for international terrorism or global warming, have. Most people have a strong opinion on globalization, and all of them express an interest in the well-being of the world's poor. The financial press and influential international officials confidently assert that global free markets expand the horizons for the poor, whereas activist-protesters hold the opposite belief with equal intensity. Yet the strength of people's conviction is often in inverse proportion to the amount of robust factual evidence they have.As is common in contentious public debates, different people mean different things by the same word. Some interpret "globalization" to mean the global reach of communications technology and capital movements, some think of the outsourcing by domestic companies in rich countries, and others see globalization as a byword for...
50 comments
Read more

LEARNING DISABILITIES

The term learning disability refers to many different types of learning issues that can vary widely in levels of severity. Students with a learning disability have at least average intelligence. They have areas of high functioning and areas of difficulties. Their learning disabilities are not caused by problem, such as vision or hearing impairments, or by primary emotional disturbance, and their challenges are not the result of poor schooling. Students with learning disabilities take in information, such as sights or sounds, but may have difficulty understanding or attaching meaning to it. They find it hard to organize information so that it is readily accessible. Retrieving the information from either short or long term memory is difficult. In addition, expressing the information, either verbally through speech or writing, or nonverbally may be a problem. Students with learning disabilities often exhibit wide discrepancies between different skills areas, in other words, they may be g...
32 comments
Read more

A TEACHER’S TRIBUTE TO STUDENTS

Teaching is a passion, and my experience as a teacher has been beautiful, emotional and fulfilling. Over the years, I’ve watched the student – teacher equation evolve: From Guru, as all-knowing to Guru as friend and equal, as someone who doesn’t always know the best. Today’s teacher and the learner are partners in the process of teaching and learning. We inspire, motivate and learn from each other; if I don’t know, I can admit it to my students. The teacher is only a facilitator; one who will help the student grow, become a self-learner. The teacher is only one of many sources. Not infrequently, there is a role reversal. With children being so tech-savy, often I am the student and they are my teachers. Has teaching changes the way I think ? Yes, most certainly. My students have shown me how to manage time. I marvel at how deftly they juggle sports, academics, dance, and theatre, for instance. I have learnt how to accept failure as I see my students taking success and failure with equan...
16 comments
Read more